Print This Post Print This Post          Email This Post Email This Post

10:12 am CST - May 14, 2009

Posted under On The Record

Concealed Carry on Campus

Laura Elizabeth Morales

In January of 2008, at the University of Texas Pan American (UTPA) in Edinburg, a 22-year-old UTPA student was walking across campus to his vehicle when he was suddenly robbed and stabbed by an assailant.  In March of 2009, just across the street from the University of Texas at San Antonio (UTSA) a tow truck driver was shot and killed. 

This year alone at the University of Texas at Austin (UT), there have been 4 assaults on campus.  These types of incidents happen across the country at different campuses and in many states.Under current state law, students on campus must resort to carrying flashlights, walking in groups at night and carrying pepper spray.  These ideas are good, but students’ odds are dramatically shifted to favor criminals.  

Campus police do a great job keeping students safe but there is no guarantee that they can respond in time to prevent a tragedy, as was shown at Virginia Tech University.

HB 1893 by State Representative Joe Driver, and SB 1164 by State Senator Jeff Wentworth, would allow concealed handgun license holders to carry on campus.  Both bills have seen bipartisan support in both chambers, but many university administrators have been strongly outspoken against the measure.

“I don’t think it’s a very effective solution to the challenges we’ve had,” said Shirley Reed, South Texas College (STC) President in an interview with The Monitor.

Unlike the aforementioned universities, South Texas College has no police force.  In 1998, a shooting occurred on campus which resulted in the injuries of one STC security guard and three students.

“Gun-free zones are magnets for killers bent on maximizing their body count. They know that they face far less risk of quickly being stopped there. There are numerous cases in which private firearm owners have disarmed or disabled those attempting to murder indiscriminately in public places,” wrote Theodore Day, Professor of Finance, Stan Liebowitz, Ashbel Smith Professor of Economics from the University of Texas at Dallas and Craig Pirrong, Finance Professor at the University of Houston in a letter printed by the Dallas Morning News.

A 1995 study conducted by the Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology at the Northwestern University School of Law concluded that “in a ten state sample of incarcerated felons interviewed in 1982, 34% reported having been ‘scared off, shot at, wounded or captured by an armed victim.’”

Disarming a concealed handgun license holder unfairly tilts the odds against the innocent bystanders, the law abiding citizens and the defenseless students going about their daily business on campus.The assumption that allowing concealed handgun license holders to carry on campus will lead to more violence is just as unfounded as the assumption that more pencils will cause longer essays on exam day.

“Since the Utah Supreme Court ruling in the fall semester of 2006, state law has allowed licensed individuals to carry concealed handguns on the campuses of all nine public colleges in Utah.  Concealed carry has been allowed at Colorado State University (Fort Collins, CO) since 2003 and at Blue Ridge Community College (Weyers Cave, VA) since 1995. 

After allowing concealed carry on campus for a combined total of more than eighty semesters, none of these eleven schools have seen a single resulting incident of gun violence (including suicides), a single gun accident, or a single gun theft,” according to the national organization Students for Concealed Carry on Campus.

15 Comments

Texaspete
1:13 pm CST
May 14, 2009

I have been a long-time supporter of concealed carry on campus. The problem is that most people have a misconception of the persons that would be carrying on campus. They panic at the thought of a student having a handgun in their backpack. Every single person that has a concealed carry license has gone through a background check at every level of government. As statistics show, licensed carriers have NEVER been the ones instigating a shooting. The police can only protect if they are present at the time of a crime in progress. The job of police is mostly to investigate AFTER a crime has been committed. They cannot be everywhere at all times. A level headed student , staff, or faculty member should be allowed to protect themselves, their classmates, and their professors.

Dennis Joyce
1:22 pm CST
May 14, 2009

Socialist/Bolsheviks continue to force childhood well into adulthood resulting in a helpless young society. Children as young a then years old used to bring guns to school and we had no problems.

We didn’t start having problems until the pill pushing psychologist and sociologist became involved in removing personal responsibility from the classrooms of America.

Get rid of all ‘gun’ laws and allow the responsible to protect themselves and those around them and you can send the police back to the station to fill out the paper work for that is the end result of a call to 911.

tanstaafl2
2:23 pm CST
May 14, 2009

Pass campus concealed carry. I’m a Va Tech almnus and I don’t want anyone else to ever have to experience this kind of attrocity.

We’ve gotten jaded and grown used to seeing these things on the news. Let me tell you, it’s a punch in the gut when you see the news footage and recognize every single building and landmark in the background.

Some university police forces are good (others are not), but they all are oriented towards maintaining some semblance of order on university grounds. Dealing with rowdy/drunk students, parking enforcement, and crowd control is their day to day concern. IF they can even get there in time, very few of them have any more training than Joe Student to stop someone on a murderous rampage. Your life and those of your fellow students will depend on your ability to take care of yourself when the next psychopath decides to make a name for himself.

Brian
3:07 pm CST
May 14, 2009

CHL holders have more to fear from the general public than the other way around. How many of you average American citizens have been fully finger printed, and had your entire life probed by the state and federal government? Anything more than a traffic ticket will disqualify you from obtaining a CHL.

Please stuff your paranoid fears and start demanding attention being paid to WHY people feel compelled to kill innocent people. It doesn’t matter if they use a gun, a knife, a spoon, or a feather. A person hell bent on killing WILL find a way to do so. Stop blaming the weapon and start focusing on the criminal activity. UNTIL that is done, you’re just spitting in the wind!

When you see signs that read, “Gun Free Zone” you should read them as the criminal sees them. (Criminal Safe Haven)

Think about it!

Anna Sentari
4:19 pm CST
May 14, 2009

try it for a couple years – if it works, let the facts support the cause – and if it doesn’t, same holds true.

R Lee
4:24 pm CST
May 14, 2009

Brian, you nailed it… thanks.

Clachi
4:42 pm CST
May 14, 2009

After reading Shirley Reed’s comments I feel inclined to question if South Texas College is having trouble finding qualified Presidents. To any one with any experience it would not take long to ascertain that a concealed handgun licensed student is much safer than an unlicensed criminal. However, Shirley Reed does not seem to see it that way.

When a person is issued a Concealed Handgun License they do not show off, it caused them to grow up, fast. The responsibility is awesome and I have seen boys grow up so fast it is hard to believe. It will surely cut down on some of the silly things they tend to do while in College. So it would serve to help on two fronts, crime and college pranks.

Terry
5:33 pm CST
May 14, 2009

As we all know “An Armed Society is a Polite Society”.
Not so in GUN FREE ZONES.

These area’s attract serial murderers, because to them it means “OPEN SEASON ZONE”, with little fear of reprisal or swift action………………

Were “I” a college aged adult today, I would Carry Concealed even w/out a License………..as much as I hate to say it.

It’s still better to be “Judged by 12, than carried by 6″.

OLD COWBOY
6:51 pm CST
May 14, 2009

THE ONES WHO DON’T WANT GUNS CARRIED ON CAMPUS BY ANYONE BUT THE CRIMINALS ARE THE BIG PROBLEM. THOSE FOLKS SHOULD JUST NOT WASTE OUR $ OCCUPYING SPACE ON THE CAMPUSES SUPPORTED BY MY TAX $.

WE HAVE TOO MANY SOCIALIST IDIOTS RUNNING OUR UNIVERSITIES (& “TEACHING” THERE………). THESE ARE SOME OF THE FOLKS WHO SHOULD BE REQUIRED TO FIND JOBS ASSISTING THE ILLEGAL ALIENS DOING LANDSCAPING WORK?

A Dumas
7:43 pm CST
May 14, 2009

My children attend universities in Texas, and the thought of some burnt-out social misfit carrying a concealed handgun around the campus is rather sobering.

However, most do not understand that is not the licensed owners we need to worry about. With few exceptions, licensed gun owners are responsible and (by default) law abiding citizens. It is the psycho whack-jobs that we need to worry about.

Statistics show that violent crimes have actually dropped in regions where handgun permits are issued. Allowing the campus to be a carry zone is simply employing an additional level of security against the next college tragedy.

Freedom4All
8:58 am CST
May 14, 2009

“After allowing concealed carry on campus for a combined total of more than eighty semesters, none of these eleven schools have seen a single resulting incident of gun violence (including suicides), a single gun accident, or a single gun theft,” according to the national organization Students for Concealed Carry on Campus.”

SCCC has provided no evidence for that claim whatsoever. The truth is that not 1 of those 11 schools has published data on campus offenses that breaks them down by weapon type, or by whether the offender was a concealed carry permit holder or not.

When asked to provide a source for these claims (the names of the officers they spoke to, the dates, and the notes of their conversations), SCCC has been silent.

Common Sense?
9:02 am CST
May 14, 2009

Four assaults on a campus in a 4 1/2 month period (none of which resulted in death or severe injury, apparently) is evidence that students and faculty on a campus should be armed? An assault could be something as simple as a fistfight.

The truth is that “gun free zones” in the United States are BY FAR the safest places in the country, with miniscule violent crime and homicide rates.

A 2005 study by the Department of Justice found that 93% of violent crimes that victimize college students occur OFF campus, in the “gun full zones” that SCCC tells us will protect us.

No thanks…

Stressed Out
10:41 am CST
May 14, 2009

Aleksandr Dumas writes, “My children attend universities in Texas, and the thought of some burnt-out social misfit carrying a concealed handgun around the campus is rather sobering. However, most do not understand that is not the licensed owners we need to worry about. With few exceptions, licensed gun owners are responsible and (by default) law abiding citizens. It is the psycho whack-jobs that we need to worry about.”

Even good people make mistakes, as illustrated by the soldier in Iraq who shot eight people. His gun had been taken away, he was being treated for stress; and he took the gun away from someone who was lawfully armed and shot other lawfully armed individuals. That’s the kind of thing that can go wrong if you start introducing guns into stressful environments. Obviously we need guns to go to war–but we don’t need them in a classroom. We’re not at war.

There is so little crime on campus, you’re nuts to carry a gun there. It’s just asking for something to go wrong. Simple assault, theft happens all the time. No gun necessary. Aggravated assault, homicide, even rape–very rare on college campuses. Especially compared to the surrounding areas. Even the DOJ says the vast majority of violent crimes against students happen off campus.

rcg
3:23 pm CST
May 14, 2009

Being a CHL holder and supporting these bills, I can guarantee you one thing. If this doesn’t pass and I’m ever on campus, get attacked, shot, stabbed, or whatever and survive, I will sue the living daylights out of the University for denying my right to protect myself to the maniacs that live to take advantage of those unable to properly protect themselves.

Texas Graduate Student
3:22 pm CST
May 14, 2009

Stressed Out- You are right you are perfect example of someone that should not have a CHL.
As a college student with a daughter in college I am for CHL in the Universities. The only ones that have them now are the bad guys- you think they would if there was a chance I might?? Not likely.
As an upperclassman Ag major most of us farm/ranch at my University and have shotguns in our trucks for predator control. I think the same (predator control) should be allowed inside the school. No one ever messed with me but anyone that ever followed me knew I was a rancher and my husband was a GSgt in the USMC. Marines vehicles have more stickers telling you who they are than anyone else on Earth!
My University had three sexual assaults, and 2 homicides while I attended- not near any of the Ag students. My daughters choice for schools here in Texas had more crime than mine- less ranchers. Hmmm
Being the wife of a Marine I have been taught many ways to protect myself since we were left alone months at a time while our soldiers were on duty away from home protecting all of you; believe me my entire family can shoot and hit what we aim for.
We both are getting CHL.

Leave a Comment

Your Name
(required)
Your Email
(required - not published)
Your Website
(optional)
Your Thoughts

Numerical CAPTCHA (required): 6+7=?