Education Spending: Reverse the Spending Growth Rate, with Reform

Part 4: Strategies for Reforming American Education

By Carole Hornsby Haynes, Ph.D.

Texas Insider Report: AUSTIN, Texas – In the 1982 landmark court decision, Plyler v. Doe, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that children of illegal aliens have a “constitutional right” to a free and appropriate public education with equal protection of the law under the 14th Amendment.  This court decision has resulted in states being forced to pay for the public education of thousands of illegal immigrant children, in American schools nationwide, even though many have no path to legal status upon graduatation.  

Southern border states have had a huge influx of illegal immigrants since 1982, resulting in enormous financial burdens on those states.

In Texas the greatest percentage of the identifiable costs of entitlements received by illegal immigrants is for their education.  Since more than 60,000 illegal babies are born annually in Texas, the cost to taxpayers is staggering.

According to the Texas Education Agency (TEA) report, the annual per pupil expenditure is $11,567.  That brings the cost to educate the 60,000 illegal immigrant children born in one year to nearly $700,000,000 — and that is only for one year of their education!

Texas House Representative Leo Berman stated recently that the annual cost is $5 billion for free education and free healthcare for the 2.5 million illegal aliens living in Texas.

Small wonder that our Texas budget is so bloated!

That money could be spent to fund the shortfall in the education budget!

Because of leftist judges, Texans are being forced to educate children who are the responsibility of other countries. 

How did we arrive at this bizarre junction?

The Fourteenth Amendment, ratified in 1868, states that, “All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside.”  Its purpose was to overrule the Dred Scott decision, which declared African Americans could not be citizens.   

American Indians were denied citizenship initially because they were subject to the jurisdiction of their own tribal governments and not to the United States.  

According to the wording of the14th Amendment, a woman who was not born or naturalized in the U.S. is not a citizen and is not subject to the jurisdiction of the U.S.  If that woman gives birth to a baby on U.S. soil, that baby is subject to the jurisdiction of the mother’s country and not to the U.S.  Therefore, the baby cannot automatically be an American citizen.  

That is, until the Plyler v. Doe decision gave automatic U.S. citizenship to anyone born on U.S. soil regardless of the citizenship status of the parents.

Now, because of activist Supreme Court Justices seeking to rule Americans from the bench by judicial supremacy, illegal pregnant women can come to U.S. soil to give birth with the tab picked up by taxpayers, who also include gift to baby of U.S. citizenship with all American rights and privileges.

In addition, taxpayers must provide other highly lucrative baby gifts of free medical care, free education, food stamps, and Temporary Assistance to Needy Families.

Next chain migration begins when the “anchor baby” reaches adulthood and is free to legalize his parents, a foreign spouse, and foreign siblings all of whom can, in turn, bring in the whole family entourage. 

No wonder our federal budget is so bloated!

Not only are large numbers of illegal aliens crossing our southern borders in a steady flow, but the “birth tourism” industry lures expectant mothers from all over the world, including China and Turkey, to give birth in the U.S. for the purpose of obtaining citizenship. The Turkish owned upper eastside luxury hotel, the Marmara Manhattan, markets birth tourism packages to expectant mothers abroad for a tidy sum of $8,000.

The Pew Hispanic Center, a research organization in Washington, D.C., reports that unauthorized immigrants are having babies in the United States at a higher rate than the general population.  Between 300,000-400,000 babies are born annually to illegal mothers, accounting for 8-10 percent of all babies born in the U.S.

The children of illegal immigrants, who tend to be very poor and lacking in education and skills, are immediately eligible for every social program offered in the U.S.   The burden falls on American citizens who are continually gouged for more taxes to support the welfare programs legislated by our liberal politicians.

The United States is one of the few remaining countries to grant citizenship to all children born on its soil. The United Kingdom, Ireland, India and Australia, among others, have since revised their birthright laws, no longer allowing every child born on their soil to receive citizenship.

In recent months thousands of illegal aliens have held demonstrations to demand more handouts and threatened continued violence and shooting of police until their demands are met.  Many are demanding that their Hispanic culture be preserved and that the U.S. change its national language from English.

The signs displayed at the demonstrations are appalling and should wake up any wild-eyed sympathizer who wants to grant amnesty to millions of people who knew all along they were breaking the law.  They strum at our heart strings with their pleadings that it is cruel to deport people and separate families.  

When people break the law, they must bear the responsibility and accept the penalty.  We cannot change the law in midstream to absolve them of their guilt.  Nor should we bear any responsibility—or feelings of guilt–for their family problems which they have created.

This is a far different group of immigrants from those who have come to America in the past.

Earlier immigrants:

  1. Assimilated & learned the customs and laws of their new land
  2. Learned English and worked hard to build a new & better life for themselves and their families
  3. Were fiercely independent and took responsibility for their own lives, instead of seeking government handouts
  4. Were grateful for the unlimited opportunities available in America, and
  5. Looked forward with great pride to becoming American citizen

Where do we place blame for the insanity of this anchor baby scheme and the financial burdens that are threatening to bankrupt our nation and states?   

Blame belongs to our elected officials in Congress who have allowed the Supreme Court to usurp their Constitutional power to enforce the 14th Amendment. 

Congress also must accept blame for continuing to pass legislation for expensive welfare programs that destroy individual initiative and self respect, create dysfunctional family units, and burden Americans with debt to pay for the upkeep of people who knowingly break our laws and then demand to be financially supported and handed American citizenship.

Blame also belongs to the Supreme Court Justices who believe the Constitution has given them the right to be the final arbiter on what is constitutional. They have no fear of their masters because they enjoy appointed lifetime positions without having to bear responsibility to the electorate for their unconstitutional judicial opinions.

Congress has the power given to them by the 14th Amendment to solve the illegal immigrant problem.

According to Amendment XIV, Section5, “Congress shall have the power to enforce, by appropriate legislation, the provisions of this article.”

Congress alone, and not the judicial or executive branches!

However, these elected officials who have sworn to uphold the Constitution have breached their responsibility and permitted themselves to be bullied by the judiciary branch.

Any member of Congress or the judiciary – Supreme Court Justice or federal judge – who violates his/her sacred oath to uphold the Constitution is a traitor and must be removed through the ballot box or impeachment.

It was Abraham Lincoln who reminded us,

“We the people are the rightful masters of both Congress and the courts, not to overthrow the Constitution but to overthrow the men who pervert the Constitution.”

If we are going to solve the crushing problems that exist within our nation, we must be willing to tear out their roots. 

  • First, we must understand the original intent of our Founders when they wrote the Constitution. 
  • Next, we must review the numerous court decisions handed down over many decades by liberal Supreme Court Justices and federal judges who have ignored the Constitution and, instead, predicated their decisions upon other unconstitutional court opinions.
  • Then, collectively we must press forward to overturn those decisions that have wreaked chaos and financial ruin upon our nation and resulted in the loss of our liberty and rights.  
  • And last, we must rid our nation of any member of Congress or the judiciary who does not uphold the Constitution.

There is much damage to undo. 

But we can and we must undo it all….NOW!

Carole Hornsby Haynes welcomes comments at Additional information is available by visiting


  1. There are so many other issues they bring to the table.

    They are driving on our roads and can’t read English. Can you honestly tell me how that happens?What do you think that does to the insurance rates. Once again we have to pick up the tab!

    They are taking jobs Americans don’t want?

    1) Try and find an English speaking person on a construction crew…here in Texas you’ll will have to search…then try to find two windows that measure the same!

    2) Enter one of many “or what used to be many” machine shops/manufacturing plants and whisper INS and watch them scatter. It looks like the place in on holiday!

    They aren’t just taking farm labor jobs!

    The deeper you dig the worse it gets! Wake up AMERICA!

  2. OK. Lets try a different approach.

    Lets cut all taxpayer funded services that encourage the illegal immigrants from coming here. So their children are born here.. let make it mandatory that in order to use these services BOTH parents must be legal citizens.
    No more free health care
    No more housing assistance
    No more food aid
    No free school lunches
    No in state tuition.

    Lets separate those that truly come here for a better life and are willing TO WORK FOR IT from those that come here and have a slew of kids and EXPECT the American taxpayers to finance them.
    A little pride and responsibility people…
    I would love to have 6 kids but we decided on 2 BECAUSE that is what we can afford in order to make sure our kids are properly taken care of and educated using our own money. .!!!!!!!!
    Is that so hard to understand?

  3. We have a socialist President with socialist Democrats and too many spineless Republicans who won’t stand up to them, they would rather make deals and compromise because they are so afraid they might upset their constiuency back home and get voted out of office. That’s what happens when you have career politicians. A good example of this is John McCain who tries to be everything to everyone and we know that is impossible. Lincoln said it best, you can please some of the people some of the time but you can’t please all the people all the time. Even the socialist Obama is finding out you can only lie for so long before it catches up to you, even the most liberal Americans are tired of his double talk.

  4. Yep If you think that the US can support all the babies whose parents are NOT citizens then “Show Me The Money” This is part of what is breaking the finances in the US. Notice we are 14 Trillion is debt and every little bit moves it toward 15 Trillian. When does the trend reverse??? Every state is having the same trouble.. Texas is in bad shape where some hospitals have had to shut their doors because of “illegals” costs that they have to carry……Now where is that fair?????

  5. Fantastic article Carole. May God bless your effort to mold the lives of our children especially through your tea party for kids organization.

  6. Since when was being a baby “illegal”??? Until the SCOTUS redefines “jurisidiction”, you are talking about fellow AMERICANs like they are second class citizens.

    Also, Plyler v Doe has nothing to do with “anchor babies”, it has to do with undocumented children. I think you are thinking of US v. Wong Kim Arc, in which the SCOTUS decided that Arc was a US Citizen despite the fact that his parents were Chinese (foreigners), subject to the Emporer of China (not under US Jurisdiction), and left to go back to China (did not have Permanent Residence). When Arc went to visit his parents, he was denied re-entry to the US because of the Chinese Exclusion Act which banned immigration by Chinese because of the perception that they could not “Assimilate”.

    Alos, there is no mention of “women” specifically in the 14th Amendment, and actually, it could be argued that the Equal Protection Clause is one of the tools used by Suffragettes to gain the Vote some 60years later.

    Quick lesson in History, and the US Con: In 1866, Congress passed the Civil Rights Act (of 1866) “declaring that everyone (except certain Native Americans) born in the U.S. and not subject to any foreign power is a citizen, without regard to race, color, or previous condition of slavery or involuntary servitude.” This Law was vetoed by then President Johnson partly because “By the first section of the bill, all persons born in the United States, and not subject to any foreign power, excluding Indians not taxed, are declared to be citizens of the United States. This provision comprehends the Chinese of the Pacific States, Indians subject to taxation, the people called Gipsies, as well as the entire race designated as blacks, people of color, negroes, mulattoes, and persons of African blood. Every individual of these races, born in the United States, is by the bill made a citizen of the United States”. In reaction, Congress passed the 14th Amendment (a process that cannot be vetoed by the POTUS), which reiterated the CRA1866. As a USCon Amendment, this Law supersedes all laws previous.

    To read the actual debate of the 14th Amendment, you can start here, at image 2980.:


  7. Illegal aliens and their illegal babies have been the root of our problem for years costing taxpayers billions of dollars. In good times and no drug war going on along the border everyone sort of ignored the problem especially our federal government. Now that a recession has hit and we have approximately 15 million unemployed American citizens and drug cartels are taking over Mexico and shooting across the border people are concerned all of a sudden. This should have been dealt with years ago. What do you suppose would happen if thousands of American citizens crossed over into Mexico and demanded more rights or they would kill police officers? I think you know the answer to that question. We are so liberal and politically correct in the U.S. we are destroying our country. It’s time for the politicians to wake up and do somthing about this. Illegal aliens babies don’t deserve American citizenship, entitlements, free healthcare, free education or anything else. these things are here to help American citizens who have paid into the system for years.

  8. David, we can rid ourselves of this insanity but taking up arms should be our last resort. Regarding some ills in our society, we’re at the point of bearing arms and throwing off the oppressive hand of our government. :-(

  9. This madness must be stopped! We cannot pay for such insanity!

    We must demand this be stopped! How can a non-citizen have rights in this country to all the goodies we give to non-productives anyway?

  10. All right then- you have my attention. Lets get the appropriate laws to stop anchor babies retroactively so no more can get under the tent..

  11. NOW that that got your ATTENTION:
    Lincoln was the VERY BEST qualified to quote when it comes to actually DEFENDING the Constitution:)

Leave a Reply